Back in mid-September, I reported the SFMTA was considering to drop their participation in the BART Plus program.
If you are not familiar with BART Plus, it's both a BART ticket with stored value and a flash pass good for unlimited rides on partner agencies. This made it perfect for those who needs to take a feeder bus to a BART station without the need to buy multiple passes, and kept it at a simple set price structure so if you need more BART fare on the Plus ticket, you can.
BART Plus was the perfect model of a multi-agency pass, giving passengers many choices, but starting January 1, 2013, BART declared four more nails in the coffin of the BART Plus program, effectively putting it on its own death bed.
Starting January 1, 2013, the following agencies will not accept BART Plus: Muni, Samtrans, VTA and Dumbarton Express.
The only partner agencies the BART Plus ticket will be valid on after January 1: County Connection, Rio Vista Delta Breeze, Tri Delta Transit, Union City Transit, WestCAT and Wheels.
Akit's Opinions:
These severe cuts to the program will only allow access to the very small transit agencies. All the big agencies that BART Plus users have depended on for a very long time will now be forking more money to ride the big agencies for their daily commutes. The loss of AC Transit to BART Plus was its first downfall, but losing Muni, Samtrans, VTA and Dumbarton Express is extreme.
BART's reason for this: "...because they (the transit agencies ending on 1/1/13) are using the Clipper Card for travel on their systems." What a lame excuse. So what? Just because these agencies now accept Clipper doesn't mean BART Plus shouldn't be honored. There has to be another reason why... is it because BART wants more money, or does the participating agencies realize it's a severe money loss?
BART Plus will always be remembered as the perfect program for a one pass solution to ride most (not all) transit agencies for decent price. The loss of the four major agencies is horrible for commuters. Many people have been asking Clipper to create a one pass solution, but these greedy ass transit agencies wants to not be friendly and force us passengers to dish out more money for transit fares.
BART, Muni, Samtrans, VTA, and Dumbarton Express: YOU MAKE ME SICK.
Welcome to Akit.Org, home to the Complaint Department and started on February 7, 2002. Featured on: SFist, Curbed SF, SF Citizen, N Judah Chronicles, SF Examiner, SFGate, Rescue Muni, SF Appeal, Pacific Citizen, NBC Bay Area, SF Weekly's The Snitch, Streetsblog SF, and Muni Diaries.
"Akit is the man. He knows Clipper." (spenta)
"It’s a fantastic blog for any San Franciscan." (Kevin)
"Your blog is always on point, and well researched!" (Nina Decker)
"Everyone's favorite volunteer public policy consultant..." (Eve Batey, SF Appeal)
"You are doing a great job keeping on top of Translink stuff. Keep up the good work!" (Greg Dewar, N Judah Chronicles)
"...I don't even bother subscribing anywhere else for my local public transportation info. You have it all..." (Empowered Follower)
"If anyone at City Hall wants to make public transit better for all San Franciscans, it would be wise to follow Akit religiously...
or, better yet, give him a job." (Brock Keeling, SFist)
"It’s a fantastic blog for any San Franciscan." (Kevin)
"Your blog is always on point, and well researched!" (Nina Decker)
"Everyone's favorite volunteer public policy consultant..." (Eve Batey, SF Appeal)
"You are doing a great job keeping on top of Translink stuff. Keep up the good work!" (Greg Dewar, N Judah Chronicles)
"...I don't even bother subscribing anywhere else for my local public transportation info. You have it all..." (Empowered Follower)
"If anyone at City Hall wants to make public transit better for all San Franciscans, it would be wise to follow Akit religiously...
or, better yet, give him a job." (Brock Keeling, SFist)
Thursday, December 6, 2012
Wednesday, December 5, 2012
Clipper Card Changes for Muni & Golden Gate Ferry
Muni
There are three changes:
- The minimum balance on a card to ride Muni is being raised to a minimum of $1.50. Anything less than that amount will be a rejected transaction. Those Muni passengers with a monthly pass and has less than $1.50 in e-cash on the card will be permitted to ride as the Clipper card reader will recognize the pass.
- SFMTA ticket machines located at all metro subway stations will change the minimum e-cash to be loaded to the card from $5 to $2.
- SFMTA ticket machines at metro stations will allow passengers to load a maximum of up to $100 in e-cash onto the card. Currently the maximum is $300, which is the maximum amount of e-cash a Clipper card can hold.
The agency has similar changes:
- The minimum balance on a Clipper card to ride the ferry is $4.25. Anything less and the transaction is rejected.
- Golden Gate Ferry ticketing machines will load a maximum of $100 in e-cash to a Clipper card.
Akit's Opinions
These are some good changes for both agencies.
When it comes to the raising of the minimum e-cash balance on a Clipper card, this is a step in the right direction. This will greatly reduce the abuse of passengers who can rip-off the system by simply loading a nickel on the a zero balance card, ride a bus or ferry, and throw the card away. It also encourages passengers to take care of their Clipper card and reuse it.
For the metro ticket machines' minimum e-cash load being reduced to $2, this is very good for those passengers who ran out of money on their Clipper card and only have just enough cash for one more ride. Instead of making them pay for a Limited Use Ticket which wastes resources, a cheap reload is just what the doctor ordered. It's also perfect when you want to dump your leftover pocket change in the machine by requiring less coins to make the $2 load, but still, BART's ticket machines to dump change is much better and easier.
As for the maximum limit to load a Clipper card, I'm not sure of why they are asking for the change. There is the possibility that they are trying to limit the abuse of stolen credit cards, just like how BART has a limit of two transactions per credit card, per day.
Tuesday, December 4, 2012
SFMTA Should Reject Spending $1.6 Million for Free Youth Passes in Light of Muni Metro Meltdown
UPDATE: SFMTA Board approved giving free passes to youth, instead of investing money towards keeping Muni running, especially since the meltdown. Big frown! Read Tweet from Muni.
Original posting: Yesterday was one of Muni's worst days ever with two major incidents: a passenger being dragged over 500 feet when struck by a F-Market streetcar, and the meltdown of Muni metro.
Muni Metro serves tens of thousands of people every single workday, and a transformer at the Van Ness station practically ended all tunnel service within the city, therefore forcing city buses to take the brunt of transporting riders from West Portal to Embarcadero. Muni blames the transformer on the weekend's heavy rains for ruining the commute after 6PM, but fortunately service is restored to the light rail system for the morning commute.
Today at 1PM in City Hall, the SFMTA Board of Directors will be having their last meeting of the year, and I'm betting the board and citizens on the microphone will be ranting about the disruption of Muni metro. Some will put blame on the weather while others will put blame on the neglect and deferred maintenance now punishing the city.
Also on the agenda is the board will be voting on $1.6 million in grant funding from the MTC to provide free Muni youth passes for those who qualify. The rest of the grant money ($5.1 million) will be going towards a rehabilitation of the light rail vehicles. (View PDF of proposal here)
Other than my views of using taxpayer money to fund free rides for kids (I deeply oppose any free rides for kids), in light of the major Muni metro meltdown last night, I want the SFMTA Board to reject the $1.6 million in funding and change the proposal to spend that money to fixing the critical infrastructure of Muni in order to maintain operational status.
While I know $1.6 million won't solve all our problems, at least fixing certain critical components such as making sure the electrical transformers for Muni metro won't explode is more important because the metro service serves a bigger population, and not just kids who might be eligible for a free pass. I depend on Muni metro on days when I go to the ballpark, and many of you depend on it to bring you fast service to your workplace in downtown.
What would you spend $1.6 million? Making sure Muni works for all, or give free passes for kids?
I'd make sure Muni works for all. And for you kids, be lucky Muni gives the BIGGEST DISCOUNT for youth passengers versus other agencies in the Bay Area.
Original posting: Yesterday was one of Muni's worst days ever with two major incidents: a passenger being dragged over 500 feet when struck by a F-Market streetcar, and the meltdown of Muni metro.
Muni Metro serves tens of thousands of people every single workday, and a transformer at the Van Ness station practically ended all tunnel service within the city, therefore forcing city buses to take the brunt of transporting riders from West Portal to Embarcadero. Muni blames the transformer on the weekend's heavy rains for ruining the commute after 6PM, but fortunately service is restored to the light rail system for the morning commute.
Today at 1PM in City Hall, the SFMTA Board of Directors will be having their last meeting of the year, and I'm betting the board and citizens on the microphone will be ranting about the disruption of Muni metro. Some will put blame on the weather while others will put blame on the neglect and deferred maintenance now punishing the city.
Also on the agenda is the board will be voting on $1.6 million in grant funding from the MTC to provide free Muni youth passes for those who qualify. The rest of the grant money ($5.1 million) will be going towards a rehabilitation of the light rail vehicles. (View PDF of proposal here)
Other than my views of using taxpayer money to fund free rides for kids (I deeply oppose any free rides for kids), in light of the major Muni metro meltdown last night, I want the SFMTA Board to reject the $1.6 million in funding and change the proposal to spend that money to fixing the critical infrastructure of Muni in order to maintain operational status.
While I know $1.6 million won't solve all our problems, at least fixing certain critical components such as making sure the electrical transformers for Muni metro won't explode is more important because the metro service serves a bigger population, and not just kids who might be eligible for a free pass. I depend on Muni metro on days when I go to the ballpark, and many of you depend on it to bring you fast service to your workplace in downtown.
What would you spend $1.6 million? Making sure Muni works for all, or give free passes for kids?
I'd make sure Muni works for all. And for you kids, be lucky Muni gives the BIGGEST DISCOUNT for youth passengers versus other agencies in the Bay Area.
- Muni: $2 adult, $0.75 youth (62.5% discount) with free transfer.
- Samtrans: $2 adult, $1.25 youth (37.5% discount) with no transfer.
- VTA: $2 adult, $1.75 youth (12.5% discount) with no transfer.
- AC Transit: $2.10 adult, $1.05 youth (50% discount) with additional $0.25 for one ride transfer.
Friday, November 30, 2012
Free Muni on December 28th? SFMTA Board Votes Tuesday
I was looking around the SFMTA/Muni website and reviewed the agenda documents for the SFMTA Board of Directors meeting that will be happening this Tuesday, December 4th.
Other than the controversial free passes for youth proposal (at $1.6 million) on Tuesday's program, agenda item 10.8 sparked some interest...
The SFMTA Board of Directors are going to vote on a proposal for free Muni rides on Friday, December 28th, 2012. You heard that right, free rides on all Muni lines, including the$5 $6 per ride Cable Cars.
Why the free rides? It's Muni's birthday, but not just any usual birthday, it's their 100th. Back in 1912, the city's Muni service was born and after 100 years, now provides over 200 million passenger trips a year.
The SFMTA considered an alternative to have the fare at five cents, but are not recommending as it is more difficult to execute.
If all goes well, the SFMTA Board will approve this and you'll be able to enjoy going around the city fare free!
Akit's Opinions:
I personally think this is a great idea to give free rides for a day to celebrate the agency's 100th anniversary. It's great for those who are enjoying their time-off, but also gives thanks to those still needing to take public transit to work on the last Friday of the year.
While it may be free, if the city has learned a lesson from the Spare the Air free transit rides, it could possibly slow down bus lines as more people would just take a bus and just get off at the next stop simply because it's free. Others complained it turns into a moving homeless shelter. But since it's very late into the year, Muni's passenger loads should be lower.
Five cents or not? I believe charging five cents has its logistics and cost issues, including the need to print thousands of paper transfers and making sure the Clipper card equipment is modified for that one day. At least when it's free, you won't have fare inspectors writing $100 citations for failure to pay a nickel fare.
Other than the controversial free passes for youth proposal (at $1.6 million) on Tuesday's program, agenda item 10.8 sparked some interest...
The SFMTA Board of Directors are going to vote on a proposal for free Muni rides on Friday, December 28th, 2012. You heard that right, free rides on all Muni lines, including the
Why the free rides? It's Muni's birthday, but not just any usual birthday, it's their 100th. Back in 1912, the city's Muni service was born and after 100 years, now provides over 200 million passenger trips a year.
The SFMTA considered an alternative to have the fare at five cents, but are not recommending as it is more difficult to execute.
If all goes well, the SFMTA Board will approve this and you'll be able to enjoy going around the city fare free!
Akit's Opinions:
I personally think this is a great idea to give free rides for a day to celebrate the agency's 100th anniversary. It's great for those who are enjoying their time-off, but also gives thanks to those still needing to take public transit to work on the last Friday of the year.
While it may be free, if the city has learned a lesson from the Spare the Air free transit rides, it could possibly slow down bus lines as more people would just take a bus and just get off at the next stop simply because it's free. Others complained it turns into a moving homeless shelter. But since it's very late into the year, Muni's passenger loads should be lower.
Five cents or not? I believe charging five cents has its logistics and cost issues, including the need to print thousands of paper transfers and making sure the Clipper card equipment is modified for that one day. At least when it's free, you won't have fare inspectors writing $100 citations for failure to pay a nickel fare.
Monday, November 26, 2012
9th Avenue and Judah (N-Judah Outbound) is Dangerous for Passengers
Seasons greetings to all my readers and I hope you had a wonderful Thanksgiving. As some of you may know, I've moved into the Inner Sunset district and have been here for the past few months. It's always great that I'm just a short walk from all the merchants and restaurants along 9th Avenue and on Irving, especially some places I haven't patronized since I was a little kid eating Sunday breakfast with my parents.
One of the greatest perks is the ample access to public transit. On 9th Avenue and Judah, you can practically go any direction with the 6, 43, 44, and 66 lines. But the fastest way to downtown is on the N-Judah.
I love the N-Judah for its air conditioning and quick rides to downtown, but I'm really concerned about the 9th Avenue and Judah outbound stop. If you have a driver's license, you are aware of the "Do Not Pass" law which requires drivers to stop behind the last metro car door when the train is embarking and disembarking passengers. It's a matter of safety that passengers can exit the train without getting hit by an incoming vehicle.
While the city does put an effort to put stickers on the back of metro vehicles, police sting enforcement, and those big signs saying "Do Not Pass" (not everywhere in the city), this gets largely ignored at the 9th and Judah stop for the outbound trains. Every time I exit the metro, there's always a car that buzzes through; even though there's an island between the tracks and the roadway, drivers still ignore the law.
Some of you may be saying, if there's a boarding island, I can pass a metro car that's embarking/disembarking passengers? The answer is mixed. State vehicle code, section 27156 makes it clear that only a car can pass a light rail vehicle only if there's specific signage, ("safety zone") traffic officer, or police officer telling the driver to pass, but only at 10MPH. When there's no specific signage permitting passing or a cop directing traffic, then the Do Not Pass law applies.
9th Avenue and Judah at the N-Judah's outbound stop does not have any signage permitting passing a metro train, therefore it is a violation to pass it. But one big problem that I have is there isn't even a "Do Not Pass" sign at the stop. If you see the Google Streetview on the top of this blog entry, there is absolutely no signs anywhere reminding drivers about the law.
For me, I'm quite worried when I exit the metro at a surface stop. I fear that a driver will just decide to pass and I'll be the next person going to the hospital. Back in January, I had a close encounter and two other passengers exiting almost got hit too.
For passengers: Always remember to look before you take the final step off the metro.
For drivers: Respect the law.
For Muni: INSTALL A SIGN!
Wednesday, November 21, 2012
Clipper Card Readers Beeping Too Loud?
Now that everyone is used to using their Clipper card to ride public transportation, one annoying issue I've been noticing more often since I moved to the Inner Sunset where public transit options are more available to me, is how loud the card readers are.
For those who tags their card on the Clipper card readers (except those at BART and Muni metro stations), that little card reader can sure screech a loud sound to confirm your proper card tag. Depending on other background sounds being generated, I can typically hear a card reader beep from a Muni bus a half a block away (roughly 500 feet) or even a block from the bus stop.
Back when the TransLink program was in their pilot program (nearly a decade ago), the card readers didn't make the loud beep, it was a lot more quieter and a lower tone ("boop!"). Worked fine for those tagging their cards and even the error tone sounded more like a buzzer than a screeching three rapid beeps.
It is truly necessary for today's Clipper card readers to be so loud that it can be heard from a decent distance? That sound should only be loud enough for the passenger to confirm the card has been tagged. There are no safety reasons that warrants the use of a loud Clipper card beep (e.g. buses with kneeling features must make a loud beep when kneeling and raising). I believe the tone much quieter so it isn't as bothersome and annoying.
Thoughts? Suggestions? Leave a comment.
For those who tags their card on the Clipper card readers (except those at BART and Muni metro stations), that little card reader can sure screech a loud sound to confirm your proper card tag. Depending on other background sounds being generated, I can typically hear a card reader beep from a Muni bus a half a block away (roughly 500 feet) or even a block from the bus stop.
Back when the TransLink program was in their pilot program (nearly a decade ago), the card readers didn't make the loud beep, it was a lot more quieter and a lower tone ("boop!"). Worked fine for those tagging their cards and even the error tone sounded more like a buzzer than a screeching three rapid beeps.
It is truly necessary for today's Clipper card readers to be so loud that it can be heard from a decent distance? That sound should only be loud enough for the passenger to confirm the card has been tagged. There are no safety reasons that warrants the use of a loud Clipper card beep (e.g. buses with kneeling features must make a loud beep when kneeling and raising). I believe the tone much quieter so it isn't as bothersome and annoying.
Thoughts? Suggestions? Leave a comment.
Friday, November 16, 2012
Don't Freak Out: Don't Pay the Meters on Sundays (For Now)
The city is already starting to update the parking meters with new signage stating Sunday parking will be enforced in the city from 12 Noon to 6PM.
But wait... before you start feeding coins into that meter, you should read the other side of the meter that says Sunday enforcement is effective January 1, 2012.
I took a picture of this meter on Portola, nearby the Round Table Pizza.
Why 12-4PM enforcement on Sundays? Local church leaders asked the city not to enforce prior to 12 so their members can attend church without fear of being ticketed. As for me, I can still score free parking before noon to get a haircut.
Also, the meter I looked at says the maximum amount of time you can feed a meter is double the time of the regular Monday-Friday maximum. I'm not sure if this 2X policy will be effective in neighborhoods with major parking problems (e.g. Noriega, Irving, and Clement).
Also, be aware that meters within the jurisdiction of the Port of San Francisco, including near Fisherman's Wharf operate 7 days a week, including holidays; so if it's Sunday and you are parked nearby the Famous Bushman, make sure to feed the meter.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





